Is Zingerman's Creamery, LLC safe? — 2026 analysis

We analyzed every published US government recall on record for Zingerman's Creamery, LLC. Here’s the verdict, the data behind it, and what it means if you’ve bought from this brand.

Safety grade: B

Mostly clean record with isolated incidents

A small number of Class I recalls in the past 5 years. Most consumers can buy from this brand with normal caution.

Total recalls on record

Class I (last 5 yrs)

Recalls in last 5 yrs

What this grade actually means

We grade brands A through D based on their Class I recall count over the past 5 years — Class I means the FDA, USDA, or CPSC determined a reasonable probability that consumption or use could cause serious adverse health consequences or death. Class II and III recalls are tracked but don’t affect the grade.

A — 0 Class I recalls in 5 years (cleanest tier).
B — 1–2 Class I recalls in 5 years.
C — 3–4 Class I recalls in 5 years.
D — 5+ Class I recalls in 5 years.

Independent safety analysis

# Zingerman's Creamery, LLC - Consumer Safety Summary Zingerman's Creamery has experienced two recalls in the past five years, both classified as Class I—the most serious category, indicating potential health hazards. Despite this recall activity, the company maintains a B safety grade. The frequency and severity of these recalls warrant attention, though they represent a relatively small number of incidents for a food producer. Consumers should review the specific details of these recalls to determine if any products they purchased were affected. It's advisable to check the FDA's recall database for product names, dates, and lot numbers. Those who purchased Zingerman's products during the recall periods should verify their items' safety status. Consumers can also monitor the company's website or FDA announcements for future safety updates. Maintaining awareness of food safety recalls is a standard precaution all consumers should practice with any food brand.

Most common reasons for Zingerman's Creamery, LLC recalls

Based on every recall we’ve recorded for this brand since 2022.

undeclared egg2 recalls

Most recent recall

October 24, 2022 · FDA · Class I

Zingerman's Paw Paw Gelato pint (16oz) and quart (32oz) sizes

undeclared egg

Read full recall

Should you stop buying Zingerman's Creamery, LLC?

A recall on record doesn’t mean every product is unsafe — it means a specific lot, batch, or product line was pulled. Most recalls are tied to a single production date or facility.

For most consumers, Zingerman's Creamery, LLC is safe to keep buying. The smartest move is to turn on alerts for this specific brand so you find out the moment a new recall is issued — long before you’d hear it on the news.