Is Gem City Fine Foods, LLC safe? — 2026 analysis

We analyzed every published US government recall on record for Gem City Fine Foods, LLC. Here’s the verdict, the data behind it, and what it means if you’ve bought from this brand.

Safety grade: A

Generally safe based on recall history

No Class I (most serious) recalls in the last 5 years. That puts this brand in the cleanest tier we track.

Total recalls on record

Class I (last 5 yrs)

Recalls in last 5 yrs

What this grade actually means

We grade brands A through D based on their Class I recall count over the past 5 years — Class I means the FDA, USDA, or CPSC determined a reasonable probability that consumption or use could cause serious adverse health consequences or death. Class II and III recalls are tracked but don’t affect the grade.

A — 0 Class I recalls in 5 years (cleanest tier).
B — 1–2 Class I recalls in 5 years.
C — 3–4 Class I recalls in 5 years.
D — 5+ Class I recalls in 5 years.

Independent safety analysis

# Gem City Fine Foods, LLC - Consumer Safety Summary Gem City Fine Foods, LLC has a strong safety record with an A safety grade. The company has had 2 total recalls, both occurring within the last 5 years. Notably, neither recall was classified as Class I, which indicates the company has not had recalls involving serious health hazards or life-threatening situations. This demonstrates a generally responsible approach to food safety management. Consumers should know that all food companies are subject to FDA oversight and may issue recalls when safety concerns arise. Gem City Fine Foods' A-grade rating and absence of Class I recalls suggest effective quality control practices. Consumers can check the FDA's recall database for specific details about any past recalls affecting products they use. As with all food purchases, following proper storage and preparation guidelines helps ensure food safety.

Most common reasons for Gem City Fine Foods, LLC recalls

Based on every recall we’ve recorded for this brand since 2021.

Frozen desserts are mislabeled. Flourless Chocolate Torte mi2 recalls

Gluten Free Flourless Chocolate Torte mislabeled with Triple1 recall

Most recent recall

October 31, 2022 · FDA · Class II

Gem City Fine Foods GF Flourless Chocolate Torte, 4 oz., frozen gluten free dessert, clear plastic package, UPC 855026001018, Gem City Fine Foods, LLC, 3403 S 1400 W, Suite C, W Valley City, UT 84119

Gluten Free Flourless Chocolate Torte mislabeled with Triple Berry Streusel Cheesecake label resulting in undeclared soy due to soy lecithin ingredient.

Read full recall

Should you stop buying Gem City Fine Foods, LLC?

A recall on record doesn’t mean every product is unsafe — it means a specific lot, batch, or product line was pulled. Most recalls are tied to a single production date or facility.

For most consumers, Gem City Fine Foods, LLC is safe to keep buying. The smartest move is to turn on alerts for this specific brand so you find out the moment a new recall is issued — long before you’d hear it on the news.