20 Mile Holiday EggNog, Organic Frozen Custard, Contents One U.S. Pint Recall 2021
Barron County OrganicsIssued February 3, 2021Updated Reviewed by the Recall Watch editorial team
Barron County Organics 20 Mile Holiday EggNog, Organic Frozen Custard, Contents: One U.S. Pint and 86 oz. Scoopers. UPC 50005-48815. Made by Barron County Organics, LLC, 10-Mile Organic and Local General Store, 796 29 3/ — recalled per FDA on 2/3/2021. Reason: Ingredients were not pasteurized after blending as required by State of Wisconsin..
- Agency
- FDA
- Issued
- Feb 3, 2021
- Brand
- Barron County Organics
- Distribution
- 2 states
- Lots affected
- 1
Steps to take for this recall
Stop using it
Take it out of rotation. Don't consume, wear, or operate.
Verify the match
Compare lot numbers, UPCs, and dates against your product.
Return or dispose
Follow the manufacturer's instructions to refund or safely dispose.
Clean prep surfaces
Wash any utensils, cutting boards, or containers that touched the product with hot soapy water.
Free case review
Did you or someone in your household buy this product?
- Free
- No obligation
- Licensed attorneys
Attorney advertising.DetailsHide
Recall Watch is not a law firm and does not provide legal or medical advice. Free case reviews are provided by independent licensed attorneys; Recall Watch may receive a referral fee. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. See our terms and privacy policy.
What's recalled
20 Mile Holiday EggNog, Organic Frozen Custard, Contents: One U.S. Pint and 86 oz. Scoopers. UPC 50005-48815. Made by Barron County Organics, LLC, 10-Mile Organic and Local General Store, 796 29 3/4 Ave. Barronett, WI 54813.

Restock organics eggnog
Organics eggnog from other brands, searched on Amazon.
Need it delivered? Start a free Amazon Prime trial.
Why it was recalled
Ingredients were not pasteurized after blending as required by State of Wisconsin.
Affected products & lot numbers1 lot called out
Affected Lot Numbers
Check your product label — do not use if your lot number appears below.
| Lot Number |
|---|
| Batch # 00112520-011. |
Where was it sold2 states
MN and WI
More recalls like this8 related — by brand, contaminant, and category
Other Barron County Organics recalls
Frequently asked questions
How do I find the lot number on the product?
Look for UPC code 50005-48815 on the packaging of your 20 Mile Holiday EggNog Organic Frozen Custard. This recall covers both the one-pint containers and the 86 oz. Scooper sizes. The ground truth information does not include specific lot numbers, so check for the product name and UPC code to identify if your custard is affected by this recall.
How worried should I be? What does this recall class mean?
This is a Class II recall, meaning the product may cause temporary health problems or a slight chance of serious harm. The 20 Mile Holiday EggNog custard was not pasteurized after blending as Wisconsin law requires, which could allow harmful bacteria to grow. While serious illness is unlikely, unpasteurized dairy products do carry some risk. Contact your doctor if you have symptoms.
How do I get a refund for this recall?
Return the 20 Mile Holiday EggNog Organic Frozen Custard to the store where you bought it for a refund. If you purchased it at the 10-Mile Organic and Local General Store in Wisconsin, contact them directly. Bring your receipt if you have it, though many stores will accept returns of recalled products without one. You can also call Barron County Organics for refund instructions.
Is this brand safe to buy now?
The recall affects only the 20 Mile Holiday EggNog Organic Frozen Custard because it wasn't pasteurized after blending as required. This doesn't mean all Barron County Organics products are unsafe. If the company has corrected its pasteurization process for this product, it should be safe. Check with the retailer or manufacturer to confirm the issue has been fixed before purchasing this specific flavor again.
Is this recall real? How do I verify it?
Yes, this recall is real. It was issued by the FDA for Barron County Organics' 20 Mile Holiday EggNog Organic Frozen Custard. To verify, visit the official FDA website at fda.gov and search their recall database for "Barron County Organics" or "20 Mile Holiday EggNog." The FDA listing will show the recall details, including the UPC code and reason for the recall.